just as i suspected brooke white was safe (and very lucky) on american idol tonight - and tattooed carly smithson got the boot - i think people felt bad for brooke (and voted) after last night's dramatic fiasco (i gasped when she forget the lyrics and had to start again) my pal joey and i were convinced she was going to sing i don't know how to love him from jesus christ superstar which would have been the PERFECT andrew lloyd webber song for her - instead she went with that after thought of a song from evita and totally murdered it - she was horrible but i do like her - last night just wasn't her thing! yet i know in the next two weeks we will say goodbye to ms. white and syesha mercado (who kicked ass last night - totally her best performance by far!) then jason castro will leave - the finale will for sure come down to david cook vs. david archuleta (i loved his rendition of think of me last night) my votes are already lined up to make sure that mr. cook takes the idol title this year - he is also way cuter these days - the haircut is working for him and i think he lost a few pounds...at first i thought david was cute but now i think he's pretty freakin' hot! we're down to the final five - i still say this season of idol has been one of the weakest - all the hype about this 7th time around being the best season ever was just pure & simple hype! popbytes over & out for now...xxoo!
PHOTO CREDIT | FRANK MICELOTTA & MICHAEL BECKER FOR FOX
TAGS
†
MORE AMERICAN IDOL POSTS
† meet your 'american idol' top 24!
† ellen degeneres is the new paula abdul!
† oh no! pleasssssssssse - not my paula abdul!
† adam lambert steps out with his boyfriend
† adam lambert is my american idol
HOT LINKS!
† disney specifies that fake breasts are not permitted in 'pirates' gawker
† paula abdul is still looking for a new job ... the blemish
† rosie o'donnell is planning her return to daytime TV popeater
† that 'clash of the titans' remake already blows ... agent bedhead
† katherine heigl 'accidentally' flashed her boobs at showest! cele|bitchy
† kelly bensimon thinks you can skin an animal without hurting it tabloid prodigy
† want to see lots of michelle 'bombshell' mcgee pictures? cityrag
† look who can't handle aging - billy bob thornton dyed his hair! lainey gossip
† lindsay has a new sam in her life - and he has a penis! celebslam
† who wants to see brazilian hottie jesus luz in 3D? it really works! oh la la
| 
![](\"http://popbytes.com/img/goodbye-carly-simthson-1.jpg\")
![](\"http://popbytes.com/img/goodbye-carly-simthson-2.jpg\")
![](\"http://popbytes.com/img/goodbye-carly-simthson-3.jpg\")
