This is ridiculous! I am so tired of articles where women are criticized if they gain a little weight. Everyone gains weight and these two are no different. And saying that Ashlee Simpson has belly fat is ridiculous. Most people would love it if they looked like this. I am not even a fan of the Simpsons, but I am tired of seeing this kind of thing. They actually look normal now instead of like stick figures.

I aggree with the above comment completely. its like if a celebrity is too skinny they are anorexic or bulemic. then when they put on a few pounds they are fat. c'mon now. lets be real people. jessica and ashley look gorgous no matter what. get over it. we all need to stop obsessing over whats beautiful and whats not and worry about ourselves.

why did the put ashlee simpson's head on my grammy's body?

I definitely don't think that ashley weighs 137 in that second pic. I am 5'6' and weigh the same, and BUH-leve me, I don't look like that. I would say she weighs 120-something in the second and a lot less than that in the first one. Just my opinion.

your grammy must be pretty hot, bababooey.

As if the Simpson sisters are going to tell Star how much they weigh...

I'm sure the magazine consulted some 'expert' to figure out the numbers based on their body type then printed it as fact.

I wonder how many girls are going to read this article and decide they need to weigh 105 lbs like Jessica. What a great way to perpetuate eating disorders!

Shame on Star.

So they gained wait, big deal. They both still look beautiful and I think it's more a a healthy body image then most of the anorexic models that are flaunted everywhere.

I agree that I'm not sure the weights listed are entirely accurate, I'm 5'3" and about 100lbs and that first picture of Jessica doesn't seem right. I think it's partly that it's a funny angle and everything. I think the numbers are definitely exaggerated.

I guess I could get behind the "yoyoing isn't good" thing, but they're not exactly encouraging non-yoyoing with the rest of their comments.

Jessica weighed 105lbs for like 5 minutes! She worked out 7 days a week and starved herself. She looked unhealthy and once she ate normal the weight came on. Jessica is a natural curvy girl and was always fuller. Ashlee is the same. She lost weight and got too skinny but now she's back to normal. I don't get why tabloids focus on who gained a few pounds. These girls are human and I would rather see their natural, fuller body than a starving skeleton. It's so damaging for them and their young fans when all you read about is body types.

yeah they are totally off on the weights.. I could definitely say ashlee is at least 120 in the second picture. The first she was probably at 105 because there are wayyy too many bones showing!

These are woman, not little girls. Woman like these two are suppose to have curves and meat on their bones. I am so sick of this childish crap about woman being fat. You need to grow up, if you hate these woman, that's one thing, say it, but stop the fat talk, it makes young girls look at themselves and think something is wrong with them. Too many young girls are starving themselves because of morons like you!

i no those weights are not right. i would say jessica in the first pic is around 115 thats just a really bad angled picture and ashlee in the first pic is like 110. besides its not like they stopped them and put a scale on the ground and then wrote this article. this is an entertainment magazine, for entertainment purposes!